A Federal Appeals Court Rules That Trump's Latest Travel Ban Is Unconstitutional

16 February, 2018, 06:59 | Author: Inez Murphy
  • A Federal Appeals Court Ruled That Trump's Third Travel Ban Is Likely Unconstitutional

President Donald Trump speaks in the State Dining Room of the White House in Washington, Monday, Feb. 12, 2018, during a meeting with state and local officials about infrastructure.

The long and winding road to the resolution of legal challenges to the president's third travel ban stopped briefly at the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, which affirmed a district court's ruling that the ban violated the U.S. Constitution's establishment clause by discriminating against Muslims. The court upheld a nationwide injunction against enforcement of the travel ban against people from the Muslim-majority nations who have bona fide relationships with people or entities in the United States, but stayed the injunction in light of the Supreme Court order. The 4th Circuit's ruling goes further than previous rulings that only said the ban violated federal immigration law (while hinting at a possible constitutional violation), which the Supreme Court will tackle when it takes up the case in April. Under a December 4 order from the Supreme Court, however, the ban on immigrants and temporary visitors is in effect as the challenges are litigated.

In its ruling, the 4th Circuit said the ban has a "much broader deleterious effect" than banning certain foreign nationals.

The appeals court called Trump's proclamation an "invisible yet impenetrable" barrier that "denies the possibility of a complete, intact family to tens of thousands of Americans".

One judge, William Traxler, was in the majority when the 4th Circuit ruled that Trump's second travel ban was illegal. Based on that investigation, it said, the administration chose to have the ban cover a slightly different list of countries than in the first two versions.

Writing for the majority in Monday's decision, Chief Judge Roger L. Gregory said that judicial second-guessing of the president was a delicate matter but was required in this case.

Muslims in New York City pray following a protest to the mark the first anniversary of the Trump administration's travel ban by executive order. The restrictions vary in their details but, for the most part, citizens of the countries are forbidden from emigrating to the United States and many of them are barred from working, studying or vacationing here.

The 4th Circuit found that Trump had expressed "what any reasonable observer could view as general anti-Muslim bias". "The Constitution prohibits government actions hostile to religion".

In a dissenting opinion, Judge Paul Niemeyer said the 4th Circuit's ruling was an attempt to "second-guess USA foreign policy, in particular, the president's discretionary decisions on immigration, implicating matters of national security". In May, the court cited Trump's remarks on Muslim travelers while rejecting an earlier version of the ban, finding it "drips with religious intolerance, animus and discrimination".

The latest version blocks travelers from the listed countries to varying degrees, allowing for students from some, while blocking other business travelers and tourists, and allowing for admissions on a case-by-case basis.

Recommended:



Popular

Israel PM Netanyahu faces corruption charges
Police said they believed there was sufficient evidence to charge Mozes with offering a bribe. 'A RELATIONSHIP OF BRIBERY' Mr. Netanyahu said that the 2015 agreement was "filled with absurdities" and that "the more you read it, the worse it gets".

Chicago Police Cmdr. Paul Bauer was on duty when fatally shot
Tuesday evening, firefighters at a station near Bauer's police district headquarters lowered their flags to half-staff. In 2007, he was arrested for "the possession of body armor, heroin possession, and possession of a defaced firearm".

Wray Says He Won't Discuss Russia Investigation With Trump
Wray was one of several intelligence officials who warned against the use of Chinese brand smartphones. He said Russia, China, Iran and North Korea posed the greatest global cyber-threats.

Salon Cryptocurrency Miner Offers Users Alternative To Web Advertisements
Mooching off unused CPU is a novel approach-one that could either have huge financial benefits or do damage to Salon's reputation. The miner employed by Salon is developed by software firm Coinhive and it's directed to mine Monero for the media company.

Swap Neymar for Ronaldo? I´m delighted with Brazilian - Emery
Finishing second behind Tottenham in their Champions League group also exposed them to this tougher draw. Real Madrid has relied on its attacking power to thrive in the Champions League in recent years.

Toby Alderweireld left at home for Juventus match
The UEFA Champions League clash between Tottenham Hotspur and Juventus in Turin , Italy starts tonight at 1:15 AM (IST). We started not in a good way but showed we are mature enough to compete in the Champions League .

Russians Believed Killed in US Syria Attack
At least two Russian fighters were killed in USA air strikes in north-eastern Syria last week, their associates have told the BBC. The strike was the second by the US against pro-Syrian regime forces last week, according to the USA military's Central Command.

Xiaomi Launches Redmi Note 5 And Redmi Note 5 Pro In India
At a price range of Rs 9,999, the company has provided its customers with a 12-megapixel rear camera, 5-megapixel front camera. The fingerprint sensor is placed on the back of the phone and it has an aluminium unibody build, similar to the Redmi Note 5 .

Ramaphosa targets 'pressing matters' in push for Zuma exit
He said his discussions with Zuma had to be conducted with "care and purpose" and with the aim of uniting South Africans. He said Madiba's example should inform their approach to the tasks that they must undertake.

Oxfam sex scandal: Sacked staff found new aid job in Bangladesh
The Charity Commission said on Saturday that it had written to Oxfam "as a matter of urgency" to request further information. An investigation by The Times alleges the charity covered up sexual misconduct by aid workers in Haiti.