Home » World

Judge: President can't block critics

25 May, 2018, 21:44 | Author: Kristen Ingram
  • Critics have a right to critic

A federal judge in NY ruled Wednesday that U.S. President Donald Trump may not legally block Twitter users because doing so violates their rights under the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.

It took more than 280 characters, but a federal judge in Manhattan ruled Wednesday that President Trump and his aides can not block critics from seeing his Twitter account simply because they had posted caustic replies to his tweets in the past.

The Knight First Amendment Institute and the individual Twitter users claimed that by blocking users for their views, Mr Trump was shutting them out of discussion in a public forum, violating the First Amendment.

A Department of Justice spokesperson said the agency respectfully disagrees with the court's decision and is considering its next steps.

Earlier this year a judge suggested that he should make use of the mute option instead of blocking Twitter users, and now another judge has ruled that blocking critics is unconstitutional.

The case could affect other social media interactions involving public officials.

"We certainly hope that other public officials will take note of the ruling and will operate their social media accounts consistent with the First Amendment restrictions on their ability to silence critics", DeCell said.

A federal judge ruled Wednesday that President Trump and his aides can not block critics on Twitter.

President Donald Trump has made directing scorn on Twitter a defining feature of his presidency.

O'Reilly told The Outline that she wasn't particularly surprised by the court's decision today, since District Judge Buchwald had already pointed out that Trump can simply mute people on Twitter rather than blocking them.

While the Department of Justice has said that it is contemplating its next move, it's safe to assume that the ruling will be appealed.

In a lengthy discussion of what does and does not constitute a public forum, the basic argument in favor of finding Trump's account a public forum - and by extension all public official's social media presences - is that allowing for free and open debate does not in any way impinge or prevent the person for continuing to communicate.

Genevieve Lakier, a professor at the University of Chicago Law School who helped write a friend-of-the-court brief filed by First Amendment scholars, welcomed Wednesday's decision. The plaintiffs argued that Trump's twitter feed amounted to a virtual town hall, and that blocking users from seeing his tweets violated their First Amendment rights. "If all goes well, Hollywood will immortalize him as an evildoer who got his comeuppance". Trump had argued that the court did not have the power to issue a direct order against the president.

This also sets an interesting precedent as regarding other social networks; in fact, the Institute is now representing a user in a similar complaint involving Facebook, but it is too early to draw any conclusions.

All Pres. Trump's many tweets come from his trusty iPhone, and he's not shy about blocking people who use this social network platform to respond to his comments.

Recommended:

  • Battlefield V Will Have No Premium Pass

    Battlefield V Will Have No Premium Pass

    Not only do these customizations change the way your character and weapons look in-game, but they'll also impact gameplay. There will nearly certainly be a very flashy first trailer released for Battlefield 5 , along with details on key modes.
    Iran nuclear deal: European Union  looks to avoid impact of United States  sanctions

    Iran nuclear deal: European Union looks to avoid impact of United States sanctions

    According to European sources, this measure may become the EU's first step towards ditching dollar in trade with Iran. Some of Europe's biggest firms had rushed to do business with Iran after the nuclear deal took effect.
    Turkey expels Israeli consul in spat over Gaza violence

    Turkey expels Israeli consul in spat over Gaza violence

    Turkey has also asked Israel's consul general in Istanbul to leave as part of the expanding diplomatic spat between the countries. Citing widespread opposition in the United Nations to the embassy move, Mr Erdogan said: "The US claims to be powerful".
  • Move over 'yanny-laurel' debate, the 'brain storm-green needle' is here

    Move over 'yanny-laurel' debate, the 'brain storm-green needle' is here

    If you hadn't been introduced to the possibility of hearing "Yanny" or "Laurel" you may not have heard either of these words. Personally, we can hear nothing but " green needle ", but do let us know whether you're Team Brain or Teem Needle.
    Everton set to axe Sam Allardyce and snap up Marco Silva

    Everton set to axe Sam Allardyce and snap up Marco Silva

    "F*** off Sam Allardyce ", Everton fans sung during the 3-1 defeat to West Ham at the London Stadium on Sunday. Current Shakhtar Donetsk manager Paulo Fonseca is the favourite to replace Moyes.
    Siemens CEO: We can't do new deals with Iran

    Siemens CEO: We can't do new deals with Iran

    Mr Trump said this week that the 2015 nuclear deal which allowed for the lifting of sanctions was not tough enough on Iran. His moderate government is under pressure from hardliners to show toughness in reacting to the US withdrawal from the deal.
  • Frisco named fastest-growing city in country

    Frisco named fastest-growing city in country

    Rounding out the state's top three for 2017 are Murfreesboro, with an increase of 3.8 percent, and Clarksville, with 2.5 percent. Chicago's population stood at an estimated 2,716,450 as of July 1 past year , compared with 2,720,275 the same day in 2016.
    Bottas was close to

    Bottas was close to "big trouble" in Spain - Mercedes

    Hamilton is now standing at the top spot in the drivers' championship, maintaining a lead of just four points over Vettel. Had he not drawn a blank in Baku, Bottas would be a lot closer to Hamilton than the current 37 points.
    Introducing Bullets Wireless: Oneplus' First Ever Wireless Headphones

    Introducing Bullets Wireless: Oneplus' First Ever Wireless Headphones

    Generally speaking, OxygenOS is similar to stock Android, with far more customization options and a few more visual tweaks. We have embedded the Livestream for you right here so that you can learn about what OnePlus has to launch this year.
  • United States  gov't worker reports

    United States gov't worker reports "abnormal" sound, pressure in China

    In 2016 USA embassy staff in Cuba said they had suffered dizziness, nausea and hearing problems. The cause of those incidents remains unresolved.
    New journalism pioneer Tom Wolfe dead at 88

    New journalism pioneer Tom Wolfe dead at 88

    Born in Richmond, Va., Wolfe attended Washington and Lee University and went on to get his PhD at Yale before becoming a reporter. Wolfe worked as a reporter at the Springfield Union in MA and as the Latin American correspondent for the Washington Post .
    Amazon will now give Whole Foods customers discounts for being Prime members

    Amazon will now give Whole Foods customers discounts for being Prime members

    An example of one of those weekly rotating specials recently was $10 off per pound of wild-caught halibut steaks. So far, the perks are available in Florida and will roll out to all other stores starting this summer.


Popular

Texas shooting suspect's dad says son may have been bullied
Several top Republicans have called for the state to "harden" school campuses against future attacks and arm more teachers. Tuesday's inaugural session focused on school districts arming teachers and better tracking student mental health.

Jared Kushner Regains Top Security Clearance
Kushner's lawyer has said the lengthy process to obtain a clearance wasn't unusual given Kushner's business and foreign contacts. Whether the restoration of Kushner's clearance is somehow related to his cooperation with Mueller is not immediately clear.

Pompeo: 'Bad deal' with North Korea 'not an option' for US
Talks between the Koreas will likely resume after Friday, once Max Thunder finishes, said Moon's media secretary, Yoon Young-chan. There was no word on how the South Korean reporters might reach North Korea to catch up with their colleagues.

Ariana Grande pays tribute to Manchester on anniversary of concert bombing
Tweeting alongside the clip, she wrote: "so wish i were there with u all today. u have no idea. love you so v much". The ceremony included a national silence at 2.30pm to allow the country to remember those who died.

WHO raises Ebola health risk to 'very high' in DR Congo
The outbreak tests the new experimental Ebola vaccine, which proved highly effective in the West Africa outbreak a few years ago. The health ministry said two new deaths have been tied to the cases, including one in a suburb of Mbandaka.

The Explosion Geologists Feared From Hawaii's Volcano Has Just Happened
The masks do not protect against sulfur dioxide, a toxic gas that is still seeping from 21 fissures caused by volcanic activity. The crater sits within Hawaii Volcanoes National Park, which has been closed since May 11 in preparation for an eruption.

Vietnam concerned over tension in Gaza after U.S. embassy moved to Jerusalem
Israel considers the entire city its capital, while the Palestinians see east Jerusalem as the capital of their future state. Palestinians seek East Jerusalem as the capital of a state they want to establish in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip.

Vladimir Putin opens controversial Russia-Crimea bridge
Those sanctions remain in place, and have expanded in the wake of Russian meddling in the 2016 USA presidential elections. Some Russians are calling it "Putin's bridge", created to link Crimea into Russia's transport network.

Dixon Police Chief: Officer Saved Lives
The officer returned fire and struck the suspect, who was then taken into custody just west of the school , Howell said . Earlier in the day, City Manager Danny Langloss said students were gathered at the gym for graduation practice.

European Union chief on Trump: "With friends like that, who needs enemies?"
The EU and U.S. are friends and partners, therefore USA tariffs can not be justified on the basis of national security'. But at the news conference in Sofia, he was clearly not in any joking mood.